The Rationale for Half and Fully Secret Trusts.
A half-secret trust arises where property is left by will to a beneficiary and the will states that the beneficiary is to hold on trust but the terms of the trust are not declared in the will. Instead, the terms of the trust are agreed between the testator and the beneficiary.
Equity and trusts problem question (1500 words) This scenario relates to the purported creation of a trust. We are told that Michael has said to his daughter that “I promise to transfer to you within the year certain property”. The first issue to determine is whether this is sufficient to create a trust.
At the time of studying I checked whether any issue deals with half secret trust, full secret trust, their differences and links. I have asked myself whether the issues which I was reading have anything to deal with formalities and can help me to find that the distinction between half and full secret trust.
Secret trusts emerge in two forms(footnoteRef:4); a fully secret trust and half-secret trust, concerning fully secret- trust they do not appear on the will at all and no evidence of its existence can be discovered on the face of the will hence its name.
Access the links below for the essay questions and problem scenarios related to each chapter in the textbook. Chapter 1 (PDF, Size: 12KB) Foundations. Chapter 2 (PDF, Size: 12KB) Trusts in context. Chapter 3 (PDF, Size: 13KB) Trusts created expressly. Chapter 4 (PDF, Size: 18KB) Effective disposition of benefit: constitution of trusts.
The starting point to remember is that a secret trust is an equitable obligation communicated to an intended trustee during the testator’s lifetime, but this trust will be attached to a gift arising from the testators will. There are two types of secret trust which can arise 1) a full secret trust and 2) a half secret trust.
HALF-SECRET TRUSTS IN ENGLAND AND IRELAND JOHN MEE, LAW DEPARTMENT, UCC. If all you know about the Scottish Law of Contracts is that in Scotland any seriously meant promise is binding, then quite possibly all you know about the Irish Law of Trusts is that in Ireland the acceptance of a half-secret trust may validly take place after the execution of the will.
Question 2 Secret Trusts and Half Trusts s 9 of the Wills Act 1837, as amended by the Administrative of Justice Act provides that a will must be in:. At the beginning of any question whether a problem question or essay question, explain these theories!!!!! Burden of proof: Re Snowden: Burden of proof is on the person claiming that the.
Other posts on the site.
Secret and half-secret trusts are testamentary trusts that fail to comply with the Wills Act because they are not disclosed or disclosed fully in a valid will. On the facts, the potential trustees are Charles, Alex and Ben whilst The potential beneficiaries are Dorabella, Rosalind and Quentin.
At the end of the day however, the fact that the secret and half-secret trust is a necessary evil is an inescapable conclusion. The Secret Trust One of the most troubling aspects of the fully secret trust is substantiating that the primary donee has agreed to the terms of the secret disposition of the property in question.
Course-focused and comprehensive, the Textbook on series provide an accessible overview of the key areas on the law curriculum. This chapter discusses secret and half-secret trusts. It covers the enforcement of fully secret trusts; limitations on enforcement of secret trusts; half-secret trusts; and limitations on the enforcement of half-secret trusts. It also looks at the fact that secret and.
Half-secret trusts are constructive trust, because their mention in wills makes fraud unlikely; they are instead in line with a constructive notice, e.g. the use of sealed document. The House of Lords in Blackwell v Blackwell, however, considered the half-secret trust to have the same basis as the fully secret trust.
The trustee may not profit from his fraud. If the intended half-secret trust fails, a resulting trust will be set up. The effect is that this notion of the fraud theory cannot justify the existence of half-secret trusts. An alternative basis for enforcing secret trusts is the transfer and declaration theory.
In reconceptualizing the fully-secret trust, this article attempts to resolve a number of long-standing disagreements, such as why secret trusts are enforced despite non-compliance with the Wills Act, and whether fully-secret trusts are inter vivos or testamentary.
Secret and half-secret trusts are testamentary trusts which fail to comply with the Wills Act because they are not disclosed or disclosed fully in a valid will. Secret trusts represent a rare exception to the rule that any disposition on death must be by way of a will (or a document incorporated by reference into a will).
For half secret trusts, the will indicates the existence of the trust, but is silent with respect to the beneficiary of the trust. In order for the testator’s informal wishes to be enforceable as a secret trust, the testator must communicate to the legatee her intention that the rights be held on trust.